Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG): A Comprehensive Guide for Business Leaders

What is Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)?

The acronym ESG stands for environmental, social, and governance. It represents the three major factors that contribute to an organization’s sustainability and ethical impact as it relates to investment strategies. This means that outside investors looking to invest in a business consider ESG factors when considering potential investment options.

Here are the three different facets investors consider.

Environmental

This section refers to the impact a company makes on the environment. This includes things like carbon footprint, resource usage, pollution levels, and efforts towards sustainability and conservation.

Environmental considerations:

• Resource usage
• Greenhouse gas emissions and carbon footprint
• Waste and pollution management
• Energy efficiency
• Water usage
• Resource conservation

Social

This section refers to how a company manages relationships with the people and the community impacted by its operations. This includes the relationships with its employees, customers, and the community in which it operates.

Social considerations:

• Employee welfare, diversity, equity, and inclusion
• Customer satisfaction and support
• Community engagement and development programs
• Supply chain ethics, human rights, and data privacy
• Labor practices

Governance

Governance refers to how a company is managed through leadership structure. Information like how much executives are paid, business audits, internal controls, and what rights shareholders have are dictated in this section.

Governance considerations:

• Board structure, diversity, and independence
• Executive compensation
• Business ethics and anti-corruption measures
• Lobbying activities
• Risk management
• Whistleblower policies

These three areas provide an overall view of how a business operates. Documenting and maintaining a strong ESG practice makes it simple for investors and key stakeholders to understand what work businesses are doing to ensure the company is committed to positive social and environmental impact.

How ESG Works

To obtain strong investors, businesses will often adopt ESG initiatives to prove their worthiness to potential investors. Adopting environmental, social, and governance factors into an organization’s regular business practices makes them more attractive to potential investors, and can help them grow.

Here’s how investors use ESG factors as part of their qualification process.

• Screening: ESG investors typically begin by screening potential investments to identify companies that meet certain sustainability criteria. This may involve excluding companies that don’t align with an investor’s values. If an investor is looking to make more green or sustainable investments, they probably don’t want to partner with an organization that has issues with pollution.
• Integration: ESG factors are integrated into traditional financial analyses to assess the overall risk and return profile of an investment. This involves evaluating how environmental, social, and governance issues may impact a company's financial performance and long-term sustainability.
• Engagement: ESG investors often engage with companies to encourage improvements in their ESG practices. This can include dialogue with management, filing shareholder resolutions, or voting on ESG-related issues at annual meetings.
• Impact Investing: Some ESG investors specifically seek out opportunities to generate positive social or environmental impact alongside financial returns. This may involve investing in companies or projects that address key sustainability challenges, such as renewable resources, recycling strategies, and alternative energy.
• Reporting and Transparency: ESG investors typically prioritize transparency and disclosure from companies regarding their ESG performance. This allows investors to make informed decisions and hold companies accountable for their sustainability practices.

How is ESG Investing Different from Sustainable Investing?

Sustainable investments are just one part of ESG strategies. While sustainable investing only looks specifically at the sustainability portion of a potential investment, ESG strategies look at those sustainability strategies at a broader scope. It looks at how those strategies affect the social aspects of their strategy and their long-term decision-making.

Sustainable investing only considers what actions the organization is taking that focuses on the environment, and nothing outside of that scope. Investors often will use ESG strategies over just sustainability initiatives to make their decisions because it looks at the organization more holistically, and how different strategies interact to create a bigger picture.

The Growth of ESG Investing and Reporting

The growth of ESG business practices relies primarily on several changing factors in investor needs. Here are a few of the major drivers of ESG initiatives.

Increasing Investor Demand

More investors are making investment decisions based on ESG factors. This is driven primarily by a growing demand for sustainability initiatives, governmental regulatory pressures, and personal investor values.

As of 2022, global ESG assets surpassed $30 trillion and are currently on track to surpass $40 trillion by 2030. More investors are looking to make strong, sustainable choices, and establishing a strong ESG foundation is part of that.

Regulatory Initiatives

Governmental agencies around the world are now encouraging and sometimes mandating companies to make ESG-related information public to enforce accountability. For example, the European Union's Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) requires financial institutions to disclose how they integrate ESG factors into their investment decision-making processes. Similarly, the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) has developed recommendations for companies to disclose climate-related risks and opportunities.

Business Case for ESG

There is growing evidence that companies with strong ESG performance tend to outperform their peers financially in the long term. Studies have shown correlations between ESG performance and various financial metrics, including stock performance, profitability, and risk management. This has led to increased recognition among businesses and investors of the importance of ESG as a driver of long-term value creation.

New Standardizations and Frameworks

Standardization efforts and ESG reporting frameworks have facilitated the growth of ESG investing and reporting. Organizations such as the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI), the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), and the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC) have developed guidelines and standards for companies to report on their ESG performance consistently and comparably.

Stakeholder Scrutiny

It’s not just investors who are using ESG factors in their decision-making processes, but key stakeholders as well. Employees, prospective customers, and potential vendors are starting to make more value-based decisions. In a survey conducted by CNBC and Momentive, 40% of workers say they would likely quit their job if their organization took a stand on a political issue they do not agree with.

Overall, the growth of ESG investing and reporting reflects a broader shift towards sustainable and responsible investing practices, driven by changing societal expectations, regulatory pressures, and a growing recognition of the importance of ESG factors in driving long-term value creation and risk management.

Advantages of Implementing an ESG Policy

While some organizations implement ESG policies solely for regulatory reasons, there are other benefits to establishing an ESG program. Some of those benefits include:

• Strengthened Employer Brand: Providing proof of commitment towards sustainability and responsible business practices can enhance both a company’s reputation and brand value. This could lead to increased customer loyalty and positive public perception.
• Risk Mitigation: Integrating ESG practices into regular business operations can help identify and mitigate risks, including environmental risks (such as climate change and resource scarcity), social risks (such as labor disputes and community relations), and governance risks (such as regulatory compliance and ethical lapses).
• Increased Access to Capital: Many investors and financial institutions are increasingly considering ESG performance when making investment decisions. Implementing strong ESG practices can attract investment capital and lower the cost of capital for companies.
• Long-term Financial Performance: Companies with strong ESG performance often exhibit better long-term financial performance and resilience. This may result from factors such as operational efficiency, innovation, reduced regulatory risks, and improved relationships with stakeholders.
• Employee Engagement and Retention: A robust ESG program can enhance employee engagement by aligning company values with employee values. It can also attract and retain top talent, particularly among younger generations who prioritize working for socially responsible organizations. For example, providing a Carbon Savings Account for employees is a good way to provide financial benefits while offsetting carbon emissions.
• Innovation and Competitive Advantage: Addressing environmental and social challenges through ESG initiatives can drive innovation and create new market opportunities. Companies that proactively address sustainability issues may gain a competitive advantage in their industry.
• Regulatory Compliance: Adhering to ESG standards and best practices helps ensure regulatory compliance and maintain a social license to operate. This reduces the risk of fines, lawsuits, reputational damage, and operational disruptions.

Overall, implementing an ESG program not only aligns companies with societal and environmental goals but also contributes to long-term value creation and sustainable business success.

How ESG Impacts Investment Considerations

ESG factors are now a prominent feature when it comes to investor considerations. If companies want to sustain capital from a reliable source, organizations need to provide a solid foundation for ESG principles.

With global ESG assets surpassing $30 trillion in 2022, it’s clear that investors are interested in investing in sustainable organizations. Here are a few other reasons why investors choose organizations with a solid ESG foundation:

• Risk Management: Some investors are okay with making risky bets on their investments, but many are more conservative in their efforts. Organizations with ESG practices are safer investments because of their well-documented policies, labor practices, and governance behavior.
• Performance Evaluation: Investors use ESG criteria alongside traditional financial metrics to evaluate a company’s overall performance and resilience. Strong ESG performance often correlates with better financial performance, lower volatility, and reduced downside risk.
• Investment Selection: ESG considerations inform investment decisions, guiding investors toward companies with strong ESG practices or alignment with sustainability goals. This may involve positive screening to identify ESG leaders or negative screening to exclude companies with poor ESG performance or involvement in controversial activities.

As awareness of ESG issues continues to grow, integrating ESG considerations into investment strategies has become increasingly important for investors seeking to achieve both financial returns and positive societal impact.

How to Calculate ESG Scores

Calculating ESG scores involves assessing a company's performance across various ESG criteria and aggregating the results into a composite score. While there is no universally standardized method for calculating ESG scores, here are some common ways ESG is calculated.

• Data Collection: Gather relevant data on the company's environmental, social, and governance practices from various sources, including company disclosures, regulatory filings, sustainability reports, and third-party ESG data providers such as MSCI and Sustainalytics.
• Selection of ESG Criteria: Determine which ESG criteria are most relevant and material to the company's industry, business model, and stakeholders. For example, SASB uses materiality-based models that focus on a company’s most relevant ESG factors. Common ESG factors include carbon emissions, water usage, workplace diversity, labor practices, board diversity, executive compensation, and ethical business conduct.
• Normalization and Weighting: Normalize the data to account for differences in company size, industry, and geographic location. Assign weights to each ESG criterion based on its materiality and significance to stakeholders. Some criteria may be given greater importance depending on the company's sector or specific ESG goals.
• Scoring Methodology: Choose a scoring methodology to evaluate the company's performance on each ESG criterion. This may involve qualitative assessments, quantitative metrics, or a combination of both. Common scoring methods include binary scoring (0 or 1), numerical scales (e.g., 1 to 5), or percentile rankings.
• Aggregation: Aggregate the individual scores for each ESG criterion into an overall composite score. The aggregation method may vary depending on the weighting and scoring methodology used. Some approaches involve simple averages, weighted averages, or more complex algorithms.
• Verification and Validation: Verify the accuracy and reliability of the data used to calculate ESG scores. Validate the scoring methodology to ensure consistency, transparency, and alignment with industry best practices. Consider conducting independent audits or reviews to validate the results.
• Benchmarking and Comparison: Benchmark the company's ESG score against industry peers, sector averages, or ESG indices to assess its relative performance and identify areas for improvement. Comparison with peers can provide valuable insights into leading practices and competitive positioning.
• Continuous Monitoring and Reporting: Monitor changes in the company's ESG performance over time and update ESG scores regularly to reflect new data and developments. Communicate the company's ESG scores and performance to stakeholders through ESG reports, disclosures, and investor communications.

While calculating ESG scores can be complex and subjective, adopting transparent methodologies and robust data practices can enhance credibility and confidence in the results. Collaboration with industry stakeholders and adherence to established ESG frameworks and standards can further support the integrity and comparability of ESG scores.

Key ESG Metrics and Reporting

While ESG encompasses a vast range of potential factors to track, core sets of metrics have been developed that companies can use to benchmark their performance and report across the environmental, social, and governance categories.

Major ESG metrics include:

Environmental Metrics

• Greenhouse gas emissions (Scopes 1, 2, 3)
• Energy usage and energy mix
• Water withdrawal and recycling rates
• Waste generation and diversion rates
• Air and water pollution levels

Social Metrics

• Employee turnover, demographics, training, and satisfaction
• Pay equity
• Product safety and quality defects
• Data privacy breaches and cybersecurity
• Community engagement levels

Governance Metrics

• Board diversity, independence, and expertise
• Executive vs median pay ratios
• Discrimination, harassment, or corruption violations
• Political lobbying and donations activity
• Tax strategy and effective tax rate

While simply tracking these metrics is a start, best practice is to set concrete goals around material ESG factors and execute clear plans to meet defined targets. For example, companies might set goals like:

• Reduce Scope 3 emissions 30% by 2025 from 2018 baseline
• Achieve gender parity in senior management roles by 2030
• Source 80% electricity from renewable sources by 2027
• Cut workplace injury rates 10% year-over-year

The metrics and initiatives pursued should directly tie to significant ESG risks and opportunities for the specific company and industry. Regular documentation of ESG initiatives helps stakeholders understand what progress looks like over time. This allows both your organization and investors to inform major strategic decisions, craft future product strategies, mitigate risk, and help create a more sustainable corporate culture.

How to Implement ESG Strategies

Implementing new ESG strategies requires calculated thinking, consistent measurement, and buy-in from major stakeholders. Here are a few ways your organization can start to adopt ESG strategies into your regular operations.

Secure Leadership Commitment

ESG is not the responsibility of one department or individual within an organization–it’s a cross-functional initiative that requires buy-in from many different leaders. The process starts at the top, with leadership deciding to commit to ESG strategies and providing the necessary resources and authority to make meaningful change.

Some ways leaders can begin committing to ESG efforts include:

• Communicate new ESG strategies to the rest of the organization
• Establish measurable ESG goals and benchmarks
• Train managers on new practices and efforts
• Kick off new projects and sustainability initiatives
• Collaborate with HR to strategize additional plans and strategies

Pursue Certification

Third-party certifications are a great first step for organizations looking to start implementing ESG strategies. There are two common certifications that organizations receive: B Corp certification and ISO 14001.

A B Corp certification is a designation awarded to companies that meet rigorous standards of social and environmental performance, accountability, and transparency. B Corps, or Benefit Corporations, are businesses that have committed to using their profits and operations to create a positive impact on society and the environment.

ISO 14001 is an internationally recognized standard for environmental management systems (EMS). It provides a framework for organizations to establish, implement, maintain, and continually improve their environmental performance.

Receiving certifications for sustainability efforts enforces your organization’s commitment to ESG efforts. Since certifications often require specific qualifications, they require your organization to stay committed to those efforts to maintain certification in the future.

Sustainability Tools

Innovative solutions like Scope Zero’s Carbon Savings Accounts® can further engage employees on meeting ESG goals. The accounts incentivize individual employees to reduce personal emissions from commuting and home energy, advancing sustainability initiatives from the bottom up. CSAs help to reduce a company’s carbon footprint while providing an equitable benefit that can support an employee’s financial wellness. When employees participate in a CSA program, more homes will use greener methods, employees will choose eco-friendly commuting options, and the local community will benefit through less pollution.

Realizing ESG Goals

If your organization is looking to implement new sustainability efforts or obtain additional capital, establishing a solid ESG foundation is a good place to start. By prioritizing ESG strategies, your organization can reduce risk, grow with new capital, and provide a more sustainable culture for your employees to work in.

As we look to the future, the momentum behind ESG investing, reporting, and certification will only continue to grow. Companies that proactively embrace ESG will be better positioned to navigate the complexities of the global marketplace, build resilient and sustainable business models, and contribute to a more inclusive and prosperous world for all.

ESG FAQs

What does ESG stand for?

The acronym ESG stands for environmental, social, and governance.

What is ESG in simple words?

In simple words, ESG represents the three different sections in business: environmental, social, and governance. ESG strategies look at how these three major parts of an organization work together to make an impact on the outside world.

What does ESG mean for government?

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) helps play a part in policymaking, regulation, and administration. ESG strategies help to provide policymakers with a benchmark for organizations performance, and can help influence future laws and regulation when it comes to sustainability, performance, and ethics.

Reduce Scope 3 Emissions with a Carbon Savings Account

Foster employee financial wellness while reducing carbon emissions. Scope Zero’s CSA measures, reduces, and reports on Scope 3 work-from-home emissions, all while engaging employees.

Learn More